To exploit or not to exploit: the deep-sea dilemma
Our deep seabed holds hidden treasures. Or rather, hidden lives.
However, this mysterious marine life may already be endangered by mining. According to a study published in May 2023 in the scientific journal Current Biology , approximately 90% of the species present in the Clario-Clipperton underwater zone are still unknown to us.
We are 5,000 meters below the surface of the sea. It's rather chilly, around 2°C. It's pitch black and the pressure is extreme. To make matters worse, food is scarce. While the deep sea is certainly an inhospitable environment for humans, it conceals an unexpected array of flora and fauna: between 6 000 and 8 000 different species consider the Clario-Clipperton underwater zone their home.
Located in the Pacific Ocean, between Hawaii and Mexico, the Clario-Clipperton Zone is almost as large as the United States. A study conducted by the Natural History Museum in London estimates that 90% of the species found in this zone have never been described by scientific research.
Discovering marine wildlife
The goal of the London research team was to better define the fauna present in this area. To do this, they used data collected since the 1880s. These surveys were produced by scientific expeditions or mining companies, which are required to submit any potential environmental discoveries.
A total of 5 578 species have been identified, including shrimp, crabs, sea cucumbers, mollusks, sponges and corals. Of these, only 436 have a known scientific name.

Deep-sea mining
Human nature being what it is, this area is coveted for mining. In addition to marine species, manganese nodules are found there. About the size of a potato, the nodules contain manganese (of course), cobalt, nickel, and copper.
These minerals can be used in electronic components, such as cell phones, electric car batteries, and solar panels. This type of resource therefore seems essential for transitioning to renewable energy and an eco-friendly lifestyle.
These resources are therefore at the heart of the society's commitment to transitioning toward renewable and environmentally friendly energy sources. But to access the minerals in the Clario-Clipperton Zone, one must disturb an entire ecosystem that still holds many secrets. According to the authors of this study, this area is one of the ocean zones that have remained almost untouched by human activity so far.
However, these nodules are not just a mineral resource: they are also home to several underwater species. Accessing the minerals in the Clario-Clipperton zone therefore requires disturbing and endangering an entire ecosystem that still holds many secrets.
To collect this resource, heavy machinery must dredge the seabed (in the sense of scraping, not just skimming). This method will inevitably produce suspended sediment. The nodules and collateral seawater will then be transported by ships to processing plants.
Unfortunately, both these sediments, the excavation itself, and the upwelling of ores can be a danger to marine species.
Mineral resources and geopolitical climate
The presence of manganese nodules has been known since the 1960s. As a result, in 1970 the United Nations established a framework for regulating these underwater areas: 50% of the seabed was declared the common heritage of humanity.

Since the late 1990s, the International Seabed Authority has regulated its exploration and exploitation. Therefore, a contract must be signed with the Authority to exploit the Clario-Clipperton Zone or any other of these protected areas.
Contracts can be issuedto public or private mining companies, subject to certain restrictions. For example, since these deep waters are considered the common heritage of humanity, the profits generated must be shared, with particular emphasis placed on developing countries.
Protection and exploitation: creating a balance
The International Seabed Authority wishes to establish "[a] balance [between] the societal benefits of deep seabed mining, including access to essential minerals, the nondisplacement of communities, extensive deep sea research and technological development, against the need to protect the marine environment."
Currently, some resources in these deep-sea areas are already being exploited. Sixteen mining companies have been issued contracts for areas covering approximately 1 million km². These are therefore enormous areas, corresponding to nearly half the total surface area of Quebec.
How can we protect the unknown?
Conversely, some marine areas still retain protected status. They were chosen to represent the region's biodiversity. However, studies like the one in London raise questions about the representativeness of these areas.

In this sense, the authors of the scientific article place great importance on the fact that we must study the Clario-Clipperton area and its biodiversity to clarify the impact of mining.
The UN report on the matter clearly states that it is impossible to guarantee that there will be no damage to this ecosystem. This is also demonstrated by data on the impact of deep-sea mining.
In short, the abyss teems with species still unknown to humanity, and this biodiversity could be endangered by underwater mining.





Commentaires