top of page

Researchers are testing menstrual products using blood for the first time

16 juil.
4 min de lecture

There’s a first time for everything, as the saying goes…


Researchers have tested the absorbency of menstrual products using blood for the first time. Prior to this study, published in August 2023 in the scientific journal BMJ Sexual & Reproductive Health, no one had used blood in their tests. And by no one, that includes both manufacturers and researchers. Before that, they used a saline solution that was more akin to water than blood.



Tu souhaites entendre cette chronique plutôt que de la lire ? Clique ici pour entendre le balado La Tête à Papineau !
If you would rather listen to this column in French than read it, click here. Podcast La Tête à Papineau.

By 2018, advertisers were becoming slightly less squeamish about showing blood-like fluid in ads for menstrual products. Before that, blood was off-limits, and the industry relied on that familiar blue liquid instead. In 2023, the absorbency of menstrual products was tested using a red blood cell concentrate for the first time.


Four researchers from Oregon, USA, tested the absorbency of 21 menstrual products. They reached the following conclusion: the absorbency capacity stated on packages of sanitary pads or other menstrual products may not reflect reality.


They tested standard products such as tampons, ultra-thin pads, menstrual cups, menstrual discs, and reusable period underwear. Products like ice-activated perineal cold packs, normally reserved for postpartum use, were also included in the study.


Their results were as follows: reusable period underwear ranked lowest in terms of absorbency. These garments could absorb between 1 to 3 mL of red blood cells. At the other end of the spectrum, the study’s top performers were menstrual discs, with an average absorbency of 61 mL. One brand could even hold up to 80 mL of blood, which for those familiar with kitchen measurements, is equivalent to one-third of a cup.


However, it is worth noting that the absorbency ratings listed on menstrual products are not always overstated by manufacturers. For instance, ultra-thin pads, marketed as having a maximum capacity of 10 to 20 mL, were actually capable of holding up to 52 mL. It was precisely these kinds of results that raised a red flag for the researchers conducting the study.


How can a menstruating person know the volume of blood lost during their period if a pack of "ultra" pads lists a maximum capacity of 20 mL but actually absorbs up to 52 mL?


One in three menstruating people experiences heavy bleeding, defined as a flow exceeding 80 mL, during their period. Normal menstrual flow varies from person to person, ranging from 5 to 80 mL per cycle. Not knowing the true absorption capacity of menstrual products creates a risk of overlooking individuals with excessively heavy flow.


Heavy menstrual bleeding can be a sign of a more serious health issue, such as a blood disorder or certain types of cancer. Even setting that possibility aside, excessive menstrual bleeding can lead to anemia and extreme fatigue. Excessively heavy periods place a physical and mental strain on those who experience them and often diminish their quality of life.


Protections menstruelles : l'absorption des protections menstruelles, pas ce qu'on croyait...
The absorbency of menstrual products: not what we thought... Credit: Maude Hamilton

This study highlights the fact that the medical community is almost certainly overlooking many individuals with excessively heavy menstrual flow. So why, then, do companies not use actual blood to test their products?


Worse still, only tampons are required to undergo absorption testing before hitting the market. And when they are tested, it’s done using water! It is worth noting that some companies use a water-and-glucose solution, essentially, something akin to the fake blood used at Halloween.


However, while menstrual blood does contain water, it consists primarily of uterine lining, red blood cells, and vaginal secretions. Its composition varies not only from person to person but also within the same individual depending on the stage of their period. This variation affects how menstrual hygiene products absorb fluid, which certainly suggests that these products should be tested with something other than water.


One of the main arguments against such testing is the availability, or rather, the unavailability, of blood. Blood is, after all, a precious resource. Medical needs are already unmet due to a shortage of donors; does it make sense, then, to use it for testing menstrual hygiene products?


Admittedly, artificial blood exists, something these companies could certainly afford. Yet the problem remains: society already has medical needs that require blood. So, why not develop a fluid with a density similar to menstrual blood to simplify the testing process?


Making this happen requires research in the field. In recent years, approximately 600 studies on menstruation have been conducted annually (based on the average volume of scientific literature on PubMed using the keyword menstruation). By comparison, a search for studies on erectile dysfunction yields about 1,200 published studies per year, roughly double the number of publications.


In short, this study prompts us to think more deeply about the health of people who menstruate. First, regarding the medical benchmarks for what is considered heavy menstruation. But also, for anyone who menstruates, it helps to know that the use of menstrual products doesn’t necessarily reflect the intensity of the flow and that it is important information to share with a doctor, without any shame.


We must continue to open up conversations about menstruation. In 2018, menstrual blood was shown in advertisements for the first time. In 2023, the absorbency of these products was tested using blood for the first time. It is time to destigmatize this subject.

 
 
 

Commentaires


S'ABONNER PAR COURRIEL

Merci !

© 2021 par Maude Hamilton. Créé avec Wix.com

bottom of page